Pink Antler, named for the fastest-growing cells within the animal kingdom, is a brand-building company that focuses on startups. In actual fact, the corporate usually works with firm founders earlier than they also have a product. Cofounders Emily Heyward, who serves as chief model officer, and Chief Govt Officer JB Osborne began the Brooklyn, New York-based firm in 2007 with a imaginative and prescient of working with founders from the beginning to make sure each shopper firm’s id is baked into its DNA.
The pair says the kinetic hashish sector appeals to them as a result of its evolving legal guidelines and geography require flexibility and creativity. Think about, for example, the shopper with the intelligent identify who couldn’t concisely say what was within the can. Or the corporate that struggled to lift capital as a result of it emphasised the “Wow, dude!” issue moderately than its professionalism. With hashish nonetheless unlawful on the federal stage, Pink Antler additionally anticipates a shakeout as mergers-and-acquisitions alternatives and funding sources contract.
Along with working the enterprise, Heyward is the writer of Obsessed: Building a Brand People Love from Day One. Pink Antler has almost a dozen hashish or CBD purchasers, a small however rising proportion of a sprawling shopper record together with buzzy manufacturers Casper, Allbirds, Thredup, and Oova.
The dialog has been condensed and edited for readability.
Let’s begin with a primary false impression. What’s the distinction between advertising and marketing and branding? When requested about branding, quite a lot of firms reply, “I’ve a reputation, emblem, shade, and web site.”
Osborne: Branding is the clear thought your online business stands for. It’s deeper than only a description of what you do. We expect it in the end solutions the query of why individuals ought to care concerning the product in a approach that feels differentiated and significant to the target market. It’s a technique to stand for one thing the place you’ll be able to faucet right into a shopper want in a approach that feels true and emotional and never simply purposeful. Not “this widget does its factor,” however moderately “that is the function this model performs in your life and even in your id.”
Heyward: Branding just isn’t a emblem, it’s not a tagline, it’s not your identify. These issues are necessary, however they don’t seem to be expressions of why you in the end matter.
So at its finest, branding is extra than simply establishing an id. It’s establishing a relationship expectation.
Osborne: Proper.
What are among the branding points distinctive to hashish? When shoppers stroll into most adult-use dispensaries, there’s a cacophony of merchandise, however all of them look very related. Bitter Diesel is out there from many manufacturers, however there’s no technique to inform them aside until you already know what you might be searching for. The ever-present seven-pointed leaf says “weed” and nothing extra.
Heyward: There’s not almost sufficient differentiation or readability occurring proper now among the many totally different manufacturers. Ideally, we attain a regular from the model perspective the place you aren’t searching for Bitter Diesel. As an alternative, you’re searching for the brand new launch from the model you like, proper? As a result of in any other case, no matter we’re all peddling is simply generics. It’s like orange juice.
Osborne: Numerous manufacturers are attempting to be all issues to all individuals. I feel there’s a singular dynamic on this house. The demand is there, and it looks as if no matter you place right into a retailer, it’s in all probability going to promote. That’s very true proper now, as a result of there’s a newness, an pleasure about having entry. And I feel it permits firms to not concentrate on constructing a model and nonetheless be capable to promote merchandise. However I might argue it is a short-sighted technique, as a result of this class goes to see progress at a tempo not like the rest we’ve seen in latest many years.
Grownup-use hashish is now authorized in eighteen states and might be legalized on the federal stage sometime, however not anytime quickly. You might be used to working in quickly evolving industries. Is chaos engaging?
Heyward: We thrive in chaos. We’re very accustomed to working in classes the place the foundations are nonetheless being written and we’re having to regulate as we go [in order] to be nimble and versatile. It calls for creativity, and we love that problem.
It’s not simply hashish. We work in quite a lot of very advanced classes which can be extremely regulated, from healthcare to insurance coverage to [financial technology]. These are sectors the place what firms are allowed to promote can fluctuate from state to state. They aren’t all that totally different, however clearly hashish is its personal beast.
Osborne: It means it’s important to go into one thing assuming there isn’t any excellent device, since you’ve acquired to create a set of elements after which navigate.
Restriction can foster creativity, and the hashish business has loads of each. You helped develop the advertising and marketing phenomenon CANN, a THC-infused glowing water. Formally, the product is just known as a social tonic, not a beverage.
Heyward: I feel beverage and drink should not phrases that work very exhausting. We’ve labored with CANN since earlier than they launched, serving to them create their preliminary model and packaging. We helped them evolve. We had a extremely enjoyable social marketing campaign the place, as you might be in all probability conscious, we weren’t even capable of identify what the product was. That was an enchanting inventive problem. I feel it was an important instance of a state of affairs the place constraint really led to creativity, which I at all times consider to be the case.
It was a blast. Across the 2020 holidays, we created a marketing campaign that CANN was all a couple of feeling. A technique for the marketing campaign was about getting individuals to contemplate swapping hashish for alcohol in holiday-related social conditions. We created a sequence of movies that simply evoked a heat and fuzzy feeling, and the marketing campaign really carried out rather well as a result of it acquired individuals intrigued.
Osborne: We actually leaned into the notion that it is a social drink, like, that is one thing you’re going to take to a celebration, carry to the hostess, and also you’re going out dancing. This helped us overcome any misconceptions. Folks don’t wish to fear a drink will make them overly dosed, and we tried to convey this within the packaging.
How did individuals know know what the product within the movies was?
Osborne: They didn’t. It was simply intriguing.
I watched a younger man have fun his birthday on YouTube, the place he geeked out on the CANN can itself for about 5 minutes. I don’t know if he even tasted it. “You possibly can see the enjoyable packaging, there’s tons to have a look at,” he stated, describing the road drawings on the can. He was even fascinated by the flamboyant pull-top.
Heyward: The packaging is often essentially the most seen a part of the model and units up an expanded expertise.
When ought to a enterprise contemplate rebranding versus only a refresh or facelift? What do you do when the corporate grows in distribution and gross sales? When is it sufficient to simply rework an organization’s id?
Heyward: My analogy is it’s like a breakup in a relationship. By the point you’re desirous about it, you’re in all probability previous that time. It’s a extremely huge course of to rebrand, so the dialog often just isn’t even arising until there’s a extremely good purpose.
The standard state of affairs we see is the preliminary model was not set as much as scale and develop. You don’t go to market with a model that labored for a particular second in time. Not desirous about how the enterprise in the end must scale is a large mistake. To achieve success, it’s important to begin with technique, audit the prevailing model, anticipate how your model will develop, and carry out a actuality test on {the marketplace}. After which, ideally, it’s a reimagining.
Typically we do assist companies rebrand as a result of, you understand, the class shifted or they realized they’ve a possibility to go after a distinct target market. It’s at all times emotional. Usually, the child step just isn’t a good suggestion. Don’t have this dialog once more in a 12 months.
How does the branding course of differ between business-to-business and business-to-consumer purposes?
Osborne: We’ve finished quite a lot of B2B in non-cannabis classes, and I’d say the distinction is lower than individuals suppose. There’s nonetheless a human on the opposite finish having to decide. Honestly, with B2B it’s really much more difficult, as a result of there’s often a number of people who need to weigh in on the choice. The manufacturers that do the perfect within the B2B house are making their model less complicated and extra compelling.
Heyward: Concerning B2B, we don’t see a distinction in branding itself, however the distinction performs out in the place the model exhibits up, which audiences you are attempting to focus on, and what kinds of ways or messaging shall be only. Seeing [B2B and B2C] as separate usually can result in making the mistaken choices and avoiding crucial threat.
So, I’ve to ask about MedMen, which I don’t suppose you’ve labored with. Would you care to touch upon the rise and fall of an organization with such sturdy model recognition? The founders positioned the chain as a retailer for grown-ups, “the Apple Retailer of weed.” They even wowed buyers on the Canadian Securities Trade.
Osborne: We haven’t [worked with MedMen]. That’s an organization that differentiated itself in a short time. MedMen created quite a lot of noise, which then means they’ve consciousness. However in addition they had rather a lot much less dialog with clients.
Heyward: I’ll say this: After I’m visiting [Los Angeles], it has traditionally been simpler for me to go to MedMen as a result of I already know what I’m going to get there. Typically I desire a stage of predictability versus attempting to hunt out the cool nook dispensary the place I do not know whether or not I’m going to be welcome or whether or not they have a variety I need. MedMen is much less attention-grabbing, nevertheless it’s dependable.
How can a model do harm management? What may an organization do sooner or later when there’s one other deadly vape disaster or a brand new research finds THC does extra harm than alcohol?
Osborne: That’s the business, not the product. Most frequently, what we’ve seen is a product launches and it really works, so demand typically far outpaces provide. And it’s a reasonably frequent start-up problem. I’ve labored with firms like Allbirds and Casper, the place the problem for the enterprise turns into whether or not you may make the product on the tempo persons are ordering it. That’s frequent in younger companies, since you’ve acquired restricted funds and it’s important to produce a amount earlier than you understand the market.
What about scaling up? We’re speaking about hashish, however I additionally was desirous about craft beer. Microbrewers often begin as a beloved neighborhood brewery and, if the product is profitable, InBev scoops them up they usually lose their cachet. Goose Island began as a brewpub, and now you should purchase the model in grocery shops.
Heyward: That’s an important comparability. I feel it’s the identical with espresso. That sector has related challenges as hashish in that you’ve got aficionados who’re very all in favour of understanding the perfect of the perfect. That’s why you could defend your model. You run right into a threat the place, as you develop, you possibly can lose your modern shoppers.
Osborne: Authenticity and credibility are essentially the most tough to scale, however Brooklyn Brewery did it. Their lager is in all places, however they nonetheless make revered microbrews.
The hashish business will develop incrementally till it turns into authorized on the federal stage. What’s your forecast and technique for the close to future?
Osborne: The near-term state of affairs goes to be exhausting for lots of people, with restricted acquirers and restricted assets. Some manufacturers are going to get caught, as a result of there isn’t limitless capital to fund them till there are the appropriate market dynamics for them to get acquired or discover different sources of capital.
Heyward: I feel branding within the hashish house has come a good distance in a brief period of time because the legitimacy of the market has been established. We’ve advanced from the early days of stoner vibes. Many hashish manufacturers, retail environments, and even product designs are on par with or exceed what has been occurring in different classes of shopper packaged items. This evolution is fueled by the thrill of one thing so new and disruptive.
As a class grows, there’s at all times going to be opportunism — individuals attempting to leap on the bandwagon however slicing corners. You want to construct a model on high of a product you may stand behind.
Osborne: The most important market alternative is people who find themselves new to hashish and are extra seemingly turned off by clichéd imagery, claims of efficiency, and the massive weed leaf.
Photographs: Courtesy of Pink Antler
if ( window.fbAsyncInit === undefined ) {
window.fbAsyncInit = function() { FB.init({ appId : '228081358088776', xfbml : true, // version : 'v2.7' version : 'v9.0' }); };
(function(d, s, id){ var js, fjs = d.getElementsByTagName(s)[0]; if (d.getElementById(id)) {return;} js = d.createElement(s); js.id = id; js.src="https://connect.facebook.net/en_US/sdk.js"; fjs.parentNode.insertBefore(js, fjs); }(document, 'script', 'facebook-jssdk'));
}